Canadian justice at its best
- Thread starter Riffo
- Start date
Riffo
Well-known member
Sauf que Khadr n'était ni enfant ni soldat selon les conventions. Un adulte de 15 ans sans uniforme qui a lancé une grenade pour tuer. Les Américains ont fait l'erreur de ne pas l'éxécuter sur le champ et on est pris avec ce déchet.
Roy
Well-known member
Soldat de 15 ans c'est un enfant-soldat selon la convention internationale des droits de l'enfant de l'ONU, convention que le Canada a signé et ratifié
Pour la partie soldat, tout le monde est pas mal sur de ça, son père l'avait amener avec lui POUR ça. et il a commencé à 10 ans en plus.
Je m'excuse, mais peu importe son opinion, il est récupérable et on doit le réhabiliter.
De toute manière, ici c'est un état de droit, si vous voulez aller dans un état authoritarien qui exécute toutes les personnens sans tenir compte de rien, crissez votre camp ailleurs.
Pour la partie soldat, tout le monde est pas mal sur de ça, son père l'avait amener avec lui POUR ça. et il a commencé à 10 ans en plus.
Je m'excuse, mais peu importe son opinion, il est récupérable et on doit le réhabiliter.
De toute manière, ici c'est un état de droit, si vous voulez aller dans un état authoritarien qui exécute toutes les personnens sans tenir compte de rien, crissez votre camp ailleurs.
Roy
Well-known member
Riffo, on se crisse de la définition de soldat selon le dictionnaire, dans ce cas-ci, c'est la définition légale qui compte.
Selon la définition légale, c'est un enfant-soldat
MontrealM3
Legacy Member
Check out the interviews with the mother and sister.
http://vladtepesblog.com/2012/01/31/2008-interview-with-omar-khadr-sister-on-toronto-radio/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maha_el-Samnah
And the grand finale, the interview where they just let it all out about how happy they are for Canada:
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/khadr/interviews/mahazaynab.html
http://vladtepesblog.com/2012/01/31/2008-interview-with-omar-khadr-sister-on-toronto-radio/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maha_el-Samnah
And the grand finale, the interview where they just let it all out about how happy they are for Canada:
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/khadr/interviews/mahazaynab.html
Roy
Well-known member
Guess why the judge told that he had to live with his lawyer and not his family ?
Ronin
Legacy Member
Damn right.
That's called rape
Roy
Well-known member
Guess what, rehabilitation work
go in norway, where they rehabilitate the criminal, it actually work, crime rate is low and recidivist rate is low too (canada have a rate of 50%, US it's 70%, norway is....20%)
I like how people think that Justice is just about revenge for the victim, while it's not.
!Xobile
New member
Yes, but Habibi, this is not Norway... According to your own statistics, Canada has a 50% success rate at rehabilitation. These are not good numbers.
You also seems to be forgetting the fact that he killed someone... The dude deserves the full wrath of the law and should remain in jail...
Roy
Well-known member
For what end ?
If we do that, terrorists will just use him as a martyr either way (death or prison)
If we first rehabilitate him, then get him out, it's one less propaganda weapon for them.
If we just punish him, keep him miserable, for doing something on the spur of a moment in a war zone, mark my word, they will use him as a martyr
Larkee
Well-known member
Not only did he admit his crime, he said he would do it again if freed. Why anyone would want to give him another chance at killing a innocent life is beyond comprehension.
Roy
Well-known member
Dont want to be a party pooper, but the guy killed was a soldier, in a war zone.
guess what, people dies in a war